It was an emotional night on American Idol as 18-year-old Louisiana native John Foster delivered a powerful performance that left both the judges and audience deeply moved. During Sunday night’s episode, Foster poured his heart into an original song dedicated to a close friend he lost far too soon.

Titled “Tell That Angel I Love Her,” the heartfelt track was written in memory of Maggie Dunn, Foster’s late friend who tragically passed away in December 2022. The young singer-songwriter’s voice cracked with emotion as he sang the touching lyrics:

“Though we may not know the reason

It’s not for us to understand

Lord, won’t you tell that angel I love her

As soon as you can?”

By the end of the performance, with tears streaming down his face, Foster looked upward and softly said, “I love you, Maggie.”

Kristen Stewart Marries Dylan Meyer in a Low-Key Los Angeles Wedding

A Song from the Heart

Speaking with host Ryan Seacrest after his performance, Foster revealed that both Maggie Dunn and another friend, Caroline Gill, died in the same tragic incident in late 2022. The loss continues to weigh heavy on his heart, and his way of processing it has been through music.

“My whole life, I’ve always turned to writing,” Foster explained. “Maggie was one of the brightest lights I’ve ever known, and I just wanted to make something that honors her.”

In a particularly emotional moment, Foster acknowledged Dunn’s mother and her friend, who were present in the audience. “They’re the strongest women I know,” he said with quiet reverence, drawing a standing ovation from the crowd.

Judges React with Praise

The judges were clearly impressed—not only by the authenticity of Foster’s performance but also by his songwriting talent and growth throughout the competition.

Carrie Underwood, who is mentoring this season’s contestants, applauded Foster’s commitment to staying true to his roots. “I love that you keep it very traditional,” she told him. “That’s who you are. And tonight, we got to hear a sweet, tender side of your voice that honestly, I didn’t know you had. It was beautiful.”

Luke Bryan, who admitted he’d been unsure of Foster’s place in the competition earlier on, said the performance changed everything. “You’ve kind of been a wildcard for me the whole time,” Bryan said. “But what you just did there removed all doubts in my mind that you deserve to be here.”

Lionel Richie, known for his emotional insight, simply called the performance “authentic and from the soul,” adding, “This is what music is supposed to do—it connects us through love and loss.”

The Next Step Lies in America’s Hands

Foster’s emotional ballad was more than just a tribute—it was his attempt to secure a spot in the coveted Top 14. Now, the decision rests with the viewers. Fans of the show can vote via text, the American Idol app, or the official website.

Voting will remain open until Monday, April 21 at 9 a.m. Eastern Time, giving audiences a limited window to show their support for Foster and other contestants.

A Moment to Remember

No matter the outcome of the vote, John Foster’s performance has already left a lasting impact. In a competition that often focuses on vocal range and stage presence, Foster reminded viewers of the power of a story well told—and a song sung straight from the heart.

As the spotlight dims on another Idol episode, one thing is certain: Maggie Dunn’s memory lives on through every note Foster sang, and millions of viewers now know her name.

Thanks for visiting Prime Flix